| The Roses (2025) |
| Lee (2024) David E. Scherman |
| Late Night with Seth Meyers at PaleyFest LA 2024 (2024) Self |
| Self Reliance (2024) Andy Samberg |
| Good Burger 2 (2023) Andy Samberg |
| Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (2023) Ben Reilly (voice) |
| Goodbye Brooklyn Nine-Nine (2022) Self |
| Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers (2022) Dale (voice) |
| Hotel Transylvania: Transformania (2022) Johnny Loughran (voice) |
| America: The Motion Picture (2021) Benedict Arnold (voice) |
| 30 Rock: A One-Time Special (2020) Andy Samberg |
| Palm Springs (2020) Nyles |
| The Lonely Island Presents: The Unauthorized Bash Brothers Experience (2019) Jose Canseco |
| Be Natural: The Untold Story of Alice Guy-Blaché (2018) Self |
| Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation (2018) Johnny Loughran (voice) |
| Saturdays (2017) |
| Puppy! (2017) Jonathan Loughran (voice) |
| Brigsby Bear (2017) Eric |
| Tour de Pharmacy (2017) Marty Hass |
| Michael Bolton's Big, Sexy Valentine's Day Special (2017) Kenny G |
| Take the 10 (2017) Johnny |
| Pigeon Toady's Guide to Your New Baby (2016) Junior (voice) |
| Storks (2016) Junior (voice) |
| Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping (2016) Conner Friel |
| Wanna Come With? (2016) Graham |
| Hotel Transylvania 2 (2015) Johnny Loughran (voice) |
| 7 Days in Hell (2015) Aaron Williams |
| Live from New York! (2015) Self |
| Saturday Night Live: 40th Anniversary Special (2015) Self |
| The Maya Rudolph Show (2014) Self |
| Neighbors (2014) Toga #1 |
| Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 (2013) Brent McHale (voice) |
| Comedy Central Roast of James Franco (2013) Self |
| The To Do List (2013) Van |
| Grown Ups 2 (2013) Male Cheerleader |
| Hotel Transylvania (2012) Jonathan Loughran (voice) |
| Celeste & Jesse Forever (2012) Jesse Abrams |
| The Watch (2012) Casual Wanker #1 |
| Vanilla Ice Archive (2012) Self (archive footage) |
| That's My Boy (2012) Todd Peterson |
| Inside Portlandia (2011) Himself |
| What's Your Number? (2011) Gerry Perry |
| Friends with Benefits (2011) Quincy |
| The Lonely Island MTV Spring Break '88 - Highlight Reel 2 (2011) |
| The Lonely Island MTV Spring Break '88 - Highlight Reel 1 (2011) |
| The Women of SNL (2010) Various (archive footage) |
| Saturday Night (2010) Self |
| Freaknik: The Musical (2010) Chad (voice) |
| SNL Presents: A Very Gilly Christmas (2009) Mark Wahlberg |
| Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs (2009) "Baby" Brent (voice) |
| Saturday Night Live: The Best of Amy Poehler (2009) Various (archive footage) |
| I Love You, Man (2009) Robbie Klaven |
| Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist (2008) Homeless Man |
| Space Chimps (2008) Ham III (voice) |
| The Shooting (2007) Dave |
| Hot Rod (2007) Rod Kimble |
| The Shooting AKA Dear Sister (2007) |
| Nature of the Beast (2007) Leo |
| Awesometown (2006) Self |
| Football Town (2005) Johnny |
| The Backseatsman (2004) The Backseatsman |
| Regarding Ardy (2003) Ardy |
| White Power (2001) Ardy |
| Lethal Objection |
| Perfecto! |
| Awesometown - Dudes Cut |
| Vanilla Sky |
| The Robots Go Crazy |
| Super High |
| Glirk Glirk |
| 42.6 Years |
| Untitled Andy Samberg/Andy Siara Sci-Fi Project |
| Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Verse Ben Reilly (voice) |